What happened
Faculty Focus published anatomy instructor Pradeep Malreddy’s account of a two-phase practical exam: students discussed tagged structures before seeing questions, then answered individually. Malreddy reports overall performance improved compared with a traditional exam, with the largest gains among lower-performing quartiles. Student feedback was generally positive, but some students cited timing and fairness concerns.
Why it matters
The format adds peer reasoning while retaining individual assessment: discussion precedes questions, and students submit their own answers. Malreddy suggests this may help students who struggle to connect facts by exposing them to peers’ approaches before independent application. Reported gains in lower-performing quartiles make the design worth testing as a way to support reasoning without shared group scores. However, students raised concerns about answer time and fairness, and the article provides no numerical results or study details.
What to do next
Instructors can pilot the approach in one quiz, exam section, lab practical, or several stations instead of redesigning a course. Following Malreddy’s advice, use groups of three to five, hide questions during discussion, use a visible timer, and require brief individual responses without a group score. Explain that all students should contribute reasoning, and discussion ends before independent answers. Collect feedback immediately, especially on answer time and fairness. The article gives no numerical results or study details, so treat this as a teaching example and evaluate it locally.
About this briefing
Reviewed by TutorFlow Editorial. We link the primary source, preserve its publication date, and distinguish reported claims from TutorFlow analysis. Our commentary focuses on practical decisions for educators and training teams.
Discussion (0)
Open to everyone
